Before Prop 13, There Was Prop 14
In 1964, 65% of California voters put a right to refuse to sell or rent to anyone into the state constitution. It took the U.S. Supreme Court to undo it.
In 1963 the California Legislature passed the Rumford Fair Housing Act, written by Byron Rumford, the first Black legislator from Northern California. The bill barred most landlords and home sellers from turning people away on the basis of race, religion, or national origin, and Governor Pat Brown signed it into law.
The California Real Estate Association (now the California Association of Realtors) fought the bill the entire way. Once it passed, they collected over a million signatures—more than twice what they needed—to put an initiative constitutional amendment on the November 1964 ballot. Proposition 14 added the following to the state constitution:
Neither the State nor any subdivision or agency thereof shall deny, limit or abridge, directly or indirectly, the right of any person, who is willing or desires to sell, lease or rent any part or all of his real property, to decline to sell, lease or rent such property to such person or persons as he, in his absolute discretion, chooses.
The text doesn’t mention race, though nobody was confused about what it was for. The official ballot argument in favor complained that under the Rumford Act property owners could no longer refuse buyers and renters “for reasons of race, color, religion, national origin, or ancestry,” while the argument against warned that Prop 14 “would write hate and bigotry into the Constitution.”
It passed 4,526,460 to 2,395,747 (65%).

Map: Nyuuposting, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Getting rid of it
Because Prop 14 amended the state constitution via ballot initiative, the legislature couldn’t repeal or modify it on its own. Undoing a constitutional initiative in California requires either another statewide vote or a court ruling.
In May 1966 the California Supreme Court ruled 5–2 that Prop 14 violated the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment (Mulkey v. Reitman). The U.S. Supreme Court affirmed that decision 5–4 in 1967 (Reitman v. Mulkey)—meaning with one vote the other way, Prop 14 would have stood. Even after it was struck down, the dead text stayed in the California Constitution until voters finally cleaned it up in 1974.
Federalist No. 10 and the initiative process
Federalist No. 10 is about this exact failure mode. If a faction is smaller than a majority, regular voting keeps it in check. When the faction is the majority, direct democracy gives it a blank check:
When a majority is included in a faction, the form of popular government, on the other hand, enables it to sacrifice to its ruling passion or interest both the public good and the rights of other citizens.
Madison’s workaround was representative government: elected legislators, a large republic, and enough competing interests to make majority collusion difficult. That legislative process is what produced the Rumford Act in 1963, and the ballot initiative is what let a majority bypass it a year later.
Fourteen years later
Prop 13 passed in June 1978 with 64.8% of the vote, nearly the exact same margin as Prop 14. It used the same mechanism, too: an initiative constitutional amendment, drafted outside the legislature, that locks in advantages for existing property owners and prevents lawmakers from fixing it. Today its largest tax subsidies flow to long-held property in mostly white neighborhoods.
The main difference is that the Supreme Court stepped in to kill Prop 14, whereas in Nordlinger v. Hahn (1992) the Court let Prop 13 slide. Give nearly two-thirds of voters a way to write their own advantage directly into the constitution, and they’ll take it.
Corrections and data questions: info@prop13data.org.


